Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery: Discover the Best Wood-Fired Pizza in Reynoldsburg

One of the best pizzas that I have had in the central Ohio area. The sauce was flavorful and all of the toppings were fresh and tasty. The real star of the pie is the crust, very good and baked perfectly. Even though this location isn't the most convenient for us, I think that this is our new go to for pizza.

Tyler's Pizza: A Flavorful Feast! I recently had the pleasure of trying Tyler's Pizza, and I must say, it was an absolute delight! From the first bite to the last, every element was bursting with flavor. The pizza itself was perfectly cooked, with a delicious crust that struck the ideal balance between chewy and crispy. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, and the sauce was clearly made with high-quality ingredients. But the real star of the show, surprisingly, was the brownie. Forget your standard dense, fudgy brownie; Tyler's offered a cake-like brownie that was truly melt-in-your-mouth. It was light, airy, and incredibly rich, with a perfect balance of sweetness. It was a wonderful and unexpected treat, and I highly recommend saving room for dessert! Overall, Tyler's Pizza delivered a fantastic culinary experience. The combination of flavorful pizza and the heavenly brownie makes this a must-try for any pizza lover. I will definitely be ordering from them again soon!

Great taste and quality pizzas! The ingredients they use really make it better than the average shop. They have comforting plain pepperoni to some really fun and tasty seasonal pizzas too!

Being often disappointed with a lot of the local pizza offerings in Reynoldsburg, whether it be their quality of pizza or their service being garbage, we are never disappointed when we order from Tylers Pizza. Well unless we go to order and learn that they are closed for the day...but other than that I would argue that they have THE BEST pizza offering not just in Reynoldsburg, but on the entire East side of Columbus. Their staff is always so friendly and accommodating and their pizzas are to die for. We like to order a half 3 cheese and half pep/sausage/onion. Their Margarita pizza (seasonal) is also fantastic. Dont waste your time ordering from the chain pizza places, or even the other local shops...once you give Tylers a try, you'll forget all of the others.

This local pizza shop was phenomenal! I gave it a 4.25/5 and my partner gave it 4.5/5. It was delicious with the hot honey and the smoked sausage tasted so real! The couple made it feel like “home” and we definitely plan to order from them for events! We describe this experience as authentic and homebound. Also it’s not “heavy” on the stomach.

Get their calzone at lunch you won't be disappointed!! They use a sourdough dough that has so much flavor & you can taste the freshness in their ingredients!! My go to is a MYO calzone with oil base, fresh garlic, bell peppers, onions, smoked sausage, & mushrooms! By far the best pizza in Columbus we recommend it to everyone & always treat our out of town guests & they all agree- phenomenal flavor.

I absolutely love this place! We live in Colorado but when I travel out here to see family this is a must stop spot for any type of baked goods bread pizza croissantsand sweet treats. This place is amazing and Tyler treats it like it's his home kitchen. If you go to Tyler's you will not leave disappointed!!!!!

Stopped in for a little dessert. Had some blueberry bars which were loaded with blueberries, had a lot of an oatmeal taste also. Also got a cinnamon roll which had a nice frosting on top of crusty pastries that was wrapped around some cinnamon. Yummy. This is also a pizza shop. You need to check out both. Great stuff.